25 JOHNNYCAKE HILL RD
 Sales  Print  Map It


Location
25 JOHNNYCAKE HILL RD
Mblu
49/ / 15/ /
Acct#
00216500
Owner
TAYLOR COOLEY MARY B
Total Market Value
$845,000
Appraisal
$1,207,100
PID
2325
Building Count
1
Current Value
Appraisal
Valuation YearImprovementsLandTotal
2024$651,500$555,600$1,207,100
Assessment
Valuation YearImprovementsLandTotal
2024$456,100$388,900$845,000

Owner of Record
OwnerTAYLOR COOLEY MARY B
Co-Owner
Address25 JOHNNYCAKE HILL RD
OLD LYME, CT 06371
Sale Price$1,050,000
Certificate
Book & Page 468/479
Sale Date10/16/2025
Instrument00

Ownership History
Ownership History
OwnerSale PriceCertificateBook & PageInstrumentSale Date
TAYLOR COOLEY MARY B$1,050,000 468/4790010/16/2025
MCCALL SUSAN + PETER$0 0189/0945 03/20/1990

Building Information
Building 1 : Section 1
Year Built: 1730
Living Area: 2,750
Replacement Cost: $733,949
Building Percent Good: 83
Replacement Cost
Less Depreciation:
$609,200
Building Attributes
FieldDescription
Style:Antique
ModelResidential
Grade:Good + 20
Stories:2 Stories
Occupancy1
Exterior Wall 1Wood Shingle
Exterior Wall 2 
Roof Structure:Gable/Hip
Roof CoverWood Shingle
Interior Wall 1Plastered
Interior Wall 2K PINE/A WD
Interior Flr 1Pine/Soft Wood
Interior Flr 2Carpet
Heat FuelOil
Heat Type:Forced Air-Duc
AC Type:None
Total Bedrooms:4 Bedrooms
Total Bthrms:3
Total Half Baths:1
Total Xtra Fixtrs: 
Total Rooms:8
Bath Style:Average
Kitchen Style:Average
Building Photo Building Photo
Building Layout Building Layout
Building Sub-Areas (sq ft)
CodeDescriptionGross
Area		Living
Area
BASFirst Floor 1,562 1,562
FUSUpper Story, Finished 1,188 1,188
FOPPorch, Open, Finished 110 0
PTOPatio 1,096 0
UATAttic, Unfinished 1,188 0
UBMBasement, Unfinished 1,430 0
USTUtility, Storage, Unfinished 18 0
   6,592 2,750

Extra Features
Extra Features
CodeDescriptionSizeValueBldg #
FPL32 STORY CHIM2.00 UNITS$7,1001
FPLFIREPLACE2.00 UNITS$4,4001

Land
Land Use
Use Code1010
DescriptionSingle Fam MDL-01  
ZoneRU40
Neighborhood0110
Alt Land ApprNo
Category
Land Line Valuation
Size (Acres)1.20
Frontage0
Depth0
Total Market Land$388,900
Appraised Value$555,600

Outbuildings
Outbuildings
CodeDescriptionSub CodeSub DescriptionSizeValueBldg #
SPL2VINYL/PLASTIC  648.00 S.F.$13,6001
SPL2VINYL/PLASTIC  49.00 S.F.$1,7001
FGR1GARAGE-AVE  484.00 S.F.$15,5001
Valuation History
Appraisal
Valuation YearImprovementsLandTotal
2024$651,500$555,600$1,207,100
2023$351,500$340,500$692,000
2022$351,500$340,500$692,000

Assessment
Valuation YearImprovementsLandTotal
2024$456,100$388,900$845,000
2023$246,100$238,400$484,500
2022$246,100$238,400$484,500

All locations identified on Google, Yahoo, and Bing maps are approximate and may not be exact


Go To Google Maps

Go To Microsoft Bing Maps